- Clinical trials involving human subjects have long been a flashpoint between bioethicists and clinical research organisations (CROs) in India. Landmark amendments to the Drugs and Cosmetics Act in 2013 led to better protection of vulnerable groups such as illiterate people, but more regulation is needed to ensure truly ethical research.
- While CROs have argued that more rules will stifle the industry, the truth is that ethical science is often better science. The big problem plaguing clinical research is an over-representation of low-income groups among trial subjects. Sometimes CROs recruit them selectively, exploiting financial need and medical ignorance; at other times people over-volunteer for the money. Such over-volunteering occurs more frequently in bioequivalence studies, which test the metabolism of generics in healthy subjects. Because these subjects are well-paid, and get no therapeutic benefit, their only reward from the trial is financial. This results in an incentive to lie about one’s medical history or enrol in multiple trials to maximise one’s income.
- Such deception is a risk not only to volunteer health but also to society, because it can throw off the trial’s results. In recent years, several Indian CROs were found by European drug regulators and the World Health Organisation to be fudging bioequivalence data. While such duplicity by a CRO is likely to be found out, volunteer deception, which can impact data as greatly, can slip under the radar. Unsafe drugs can make their way into the market as a result, or safe drugs can get rejected. This is why volunteer honesty is paramount. But how can regulators ensure this? One potential solution is a national registry of trial volunteers, which will alert a CRO when someone signs up for two studies simultaneously. But this will need work, because volunteer privacy cannot be compromised. So regulators need to create a system that anonymises each participant’s data. Another option is to pay volunteers less, taking away the financial incentive to fudge their participation history. But this measure, in isolation, would reduce trial participation dramatically: an unacceptable side-effect because clinical trials are essential to drug research. A third, more sustainable solution is to encourage a wider cross-section of society to participate in research on human subjects. Society at large must realise the valuable service that clinical research subjects perform by making drugs safe for the rest of us. It is imperative that this burden not fall completely on the vulnerable groups. Instead, the educated and affluent, who have greater access to the drugs that emerge from clinical research, must grasp the criticality of this research and pull their weight. Selectiveness in recruiting subjects for clinical trials leads not only to human rights violations but also to bad science. Civil society’s vigilance is vital.
Flashpoint: a place, event, or time at which trouble, such as violence or anger, flares up.
Example: The flashpoint of the conflagration is just blocks away
Vulnerable: susceptible to physical or emotional attack or harm.
Example: We were in a vulnerable position
Synonyms: helpless, defenseless, powerless, impotent, weak
Antonyms: entrenched, defensible, unassailable, invulnerable, airtight
Stifle: make someone unable to breathe properly; suffocate.
Example: Those in the streets were stifled by the fumes
Synonyms: suffocate, choke, asphyxiate, smother, gag
Antonyms: stimulate, excite
Plague: cause continual trouble or distress to.
Example: The problems that plagued the company
Synonyms: afflict, bedevil, torment, trouble, beset, dog, curse
Antonyms: affection, appreciation, approval, benefit, blessing, delight
Exploit: a bold or daring feat.
Example: The most heroic and secretive exploits of the war
Synonyms: feat, deed, act, adventure, stunt, escapade, achievement
Antonyms: cessation, deliberation, endurance, immobility, inaction, inactivity
Therapeutic: relating to the healing of disease.
Example: Diagnostic and therapeutic facilities
Synonyms: healing, curative, remedial, medicinal, restorative, salubrious
Deception: the action of deceiving someone.
Example: Obtaining property by deception
Antonyms: frankness, guilelessness, honesty, openness, simplicity
Fudge: present or deal with something in a vague, noncommittal, or inadequate way, especially so as to conceal the truth or mislead.
Example: A temptation to fudge the issue and nudge grades up
Synonyms: evade, avoid, dodge, skirt, duck, gloss over, hedge on, prevaricate about
Paramount: more important than anything else; supreme.
Example: The interests of the child are of paramount importance
Synonyms: most important, of greatest/prime importance, uppermost
Antonyms: low-level, subordinate
Simultaneous: occurring, operating, or done at the same time.
Example: A simultaneous withdrawal of all troops
Synonyms: concurrent, happening at the same time, contemporaneous
Imperative: giving an authoritative command.
Example: The bell pealed again, a final imperative call
Synonyms: peremptory, commanding, imperious, authoritative, masterful
Antonyms: Mendicant, Beseeching, Petitioner, Precatory, Imploring, Supplicant